1951 – Bob McKeiver, Evanston
1952 – Frank Pinn, Mount Carmel
1953 – John Carroll, Fenwick
1954 – Jack Delveaux, Fenger
1955 – John Swain, Vocational
1956 – Ed Ryan, Leo
1957 – Mike Lind, Calumet
1958 – Jack Strobel, Fenwick
1959 – Dick Butkus, Vocational
1960 – Al MacFarlane, Taft
1961 – Jim Grabowski, Taft
1962 – Jim DiLullo, Fenwick
1963 – John Byrne, St. Rita
1964 – Chico Kurzawski, Weber
1965 – LaMarr Thomas, Thornton
1966 – Randy Marks, Loyola
1967 – Tom Spotts, Maine South
1968 – Carlos Matthews, Evanston
1969 – Barry Cernoch, Downers Grove
1970 – Ken Ferguson, Lane Tech
1971 – Bill Marek, St. Rita
1972 – Jeff Stewart, Elk Grove
1973 – Kevin King, St. Laurence
1974 – Frank Shellenback, Barrington
1975 – Mark Carlson, Deerfield
1976 – Rich Weiss, New Trier
1977 – Chris Boskey, St. Francis de Sales
1978 – Marty Finan, Fenwick
1979 – Tim Marshall, Weber
1980 – Mike Tomczak, Thornton F. North
1981 – Tony Furjanic, Mount Carmel
1982 – Eric Kumerow, Oak Park-R. Forest
1983 – Dempsey Norman, Tilden
1984 – Chuck McCree, Romeoville
1985 – John Foley, St. Rita
1986 – Kent Graham, Wheaton North
1987 – Jeff Lesniewicz, Homewood-Flossmoor
1988 – Brian Dunlavy, St. Viator
1989 – Alex Rodriguez, Lane
1990 – Corey Rogers, Leo
1991 – Mike Alstott, Joliet Catholic
1992 – Broc Kreitz, Waubonsie Valley
1993 – Greg Williams, Bolingbrook
1994 – Jason Loerzel, Maine South
1995 – Tim Lavery, Naperville Central
1996 – Mark Floersch, New Trier
1997 – Rocky Harvey, Dunbar
1998 – Philip Macklin, Proviso East
1999 – Ryan Clifford, Naperville Central
2000 – Brett Basanez, St. Viator
2001 – Tim Brasic, Riverside-Brookfield
2002 – Tom Zbikowski, Buffalo Grove
2003 – Sean Price, Maine South
2004 – Chris Jeske, Joliet Catholic
2005 – John Dergo, Morris
2006 – Dan Dierking, Wheaton Warrenville South
2007 – Jordan Tassio, Naperville North
2008 – Charlie Goro, Maine South
2009 – Matt Perez, Maine South
2010 – Reilly O’Toole, Wheaton Warrenville South
2011 – Ty Isaac, Joliet Catholic
2012 – Laquon Treadwell, Crete-Monee
2013 – Justin Jackson, Glenbard North
2014 – Dewayne Collins, Phillips
2015 – Julian Love, Nazareth
2016 – Jake Marwede, Loyola
2017 – Samson Evans, Prairie Ridge
2018 – Payton Thorne, Naperville Central
2019 – AJ Henning, Lincoln-Way East
2020 – Vaughn Pemberton, Loyola
2021 – Jack Lausch, Brother Rice